I was sitting one spring morning with my dear friend Mister Sherlock Holmes at our residence on Baker Street, when a most profoundly upsetting and strikingly singular event failed to redirect the lives of two of the most upright and upstanding of British citizens; for it was not unusual in the least for Mister Sherlock Holmes to reject instances of cases out of hand when they failed to appeal to his sense of artistry or bored him with only a common intellectual solution. That is not to say he sought out the fashionable. Mundanity always appealed to him, even from the most humblest of origins, for the simple fact of its never approaching a repetitive mundanity. Singular aspects of even the most trivial of cases would arouse his fancy and send him into the deepest concentrations of thought I have ever witnessed. But it was never, excluding this one occurrence I will soon relate, that he took to resolve a problem he deemed unworthy of his exceptionally rational mind.
We heard the bell ring while we sat in the reading room reading the news papers and soon a lady was shown into the room of exceeding beauty, fortitude, resolution, and stature as to impress the great goddess Athena herself. We, of course, rose from our soft seats to stiff postures of most respectable greeting.
The lady glided into the room, seeming to not even cast a shadow and, indeed, though the fire were blazing, for it had been a cold, wet spring, the soft violet of her eyes brought upwards the light of the room and, might I add, the temperature of its occupants.
Always with his wits about him, Holmes spoke to the lady, saying, "Greetings and well met, my laudable lady. Please have a seat by the fire and warm yourself. If there is any service at all which we can provide for you, you have never found two more willing assistants."
The lady sat on the very edge of the leather chair, knees firmly together, hands clenching a small handbag in her lap.
"What brings you upon my doorstep this day?" Holmes asked.
"I know you might judge me by my appearance;" the lady began. "I hope only that you will put aside all aesthetic significances and help me for the reason of common humanity."
"My most well spoken Mademoiselle, do let us not fail you in your moment of need; and though I understand that you must hold to neither a meager income nor an immodest one, though your resources are made all the more mean by a rather stingy man, as Master of the House, and furthermore that you spend much of your time with a great many dogs, which must mean you work in, and judging by your education and status, share in the owning of, a kennel, and though all these facts I have gathered merely from the slightest of, I must confess, longing glances, upon you, nevertheless, I will strive not to allow my prejudgéd biases to sway my determination of the case you bring to my attention. You must trust me that no subjective viewpoint of my own can dissipate my substantial powers of objective observation and reasoning.
"Thank you Mister Holmes. And I have indeed come here today to press your unique abilities into my service, for you see, my mother has..."
"By Jove, my fellow Holmes, however did you come to such conclusions," I could not resist but saying, always being most intrigued by my companions astounding scrutiny.
"Well, I would hate to interrupt the lady."
"I must know," I said. "I'm sure the lady is as well fascinated by your methods."
The lady made to speak, most likely to agree to an explanation by Holmes, but my friend was already obliging her.
"Very well," Holmes said. "To start with the most obvious first: The lady's lovely dress is bedaubed in many hairs from so many varieties of dog breeds that even I have had trouble cataloguing them all in so short a period of time. With so great a diversity, there can be only one reasonable explanation: a kennel."
"Very impressible, Mister Holmes," the lady began, "but my mother..."
"And then, proceeding to the next most obvious perception of mine: the paucity of her man of the house's generosity. Now, when a woman walks out along the streets of our great city of London, there is no doubt that every other woman in the house has taken time to make sure that every bead, every jewel, every string, every button, and every line and brush of maquillage is just in its exact place and nothing strays. So, when a woman does leave the house, and, as in the case of the exquisite lady here, a single end of the lace of her corset hangs out of her dress, and there being no doubt she has not done her very best to look her very best, then it can most certainly be ascertained that said lady has no maid whatsoever to look after her, and that she dressed herself independently. The lady having no maid, and yet the status of belonging to the middle class, there can only be one reason: the man holding the purse strings is tight fisted to the extreme."
"Very impressive, Mister Holmes, and so if you'll let me tell you the details of my mother's..."
"Thank you kindly, my sweet lady. And also from that single and might I add singular detection, it can easily be concluded that your mother is at her wit's end and is suffering indeed, for even without the privilege of a maid, your mother should have been your last resort. But she must assuredly be distracted by some great calamity to forsake the appearance of her maiden daughter. And no doubt this issue revolves around finance, for it is most unfortunate that a beautiful specimen such as yourself should be subjected to the treatment of having to wear a watch fashionable two and a half years ago. And you certainly have not had the money available to update your accessory, much less to fix its slight imperfection of its mechanism noticeable only in the garbled chink of your watch's tick, all the more so you have not had the time or energy because from your hands it is quite obvious you are forced to maintain the cleanliness of the laundry and of the dishes."
The lady wrung her hands in agitation. "Thank you Mister Holmes. You have saved me at least a great deal of explanation. You must understand, my mother is no stupid, reckless woman. Her mind is as agile as a viper and so she knew, when my beloved father died two and a half years ago, the necessity of allying with an established male to assist and to represent her in our family's business affairs.
"My mother and father opened a dog breeding kennel, as you so acutely observed, for their love and keenness for man's best friends exceeded love and passed well onto devotion. They raised their dogs, raised their own reputation, and they raised me, and as you can see they were excellent breeders. We moved well into the middle class and the clients we served were of higher and higher status. One night my father was woken from slumber by an urgent mission. A dog, not of our own kennel but of a breed well known to my father, had suddenly and rapaciously taken to madness. The caller was a very well to do client and my father took great, careful discretion in the protection of their reputation. My father arrived in due haste to find the creature had destroyed the stuffings of most of the cushions in the manse and to put it delicately, had then sought to do the same to the maid who had attempted to calm its wild with a bone. It took her arm as the bone and so it was my father found them upon his entry. He coaxed the creature...."
"Please, mademoiselle, I am at your disposal, but I cannot spend my life there. Do hurry to the denouement of your story and the reason for my involvement."
"Yes, of course. I do apologize. Well, so it was that my father left us. For a better world, I have no doubt. And yet, he left us in a world all the worse for his departure. My family's business affairs were not ready for the sudden loss of my father and so it was my mother, in order simply to gain her due, succumbed to the notion that a good alliance with a man would enable her to settle my family's accounts. No doubt her best intentions were at heart, and yet there are so many coercers out there. My dear mother assumed she'd found an honest man, but even an honest man, when presented with the opportunity for control, and especially control of a higher line of finance than the man is accustomed, may succumb to the most selfish and fearful of temptations. For, you see, Mister Holmes, my step father has now taken it upon himself to consider my family's own wealth, hard worked and difficultly won, as his very own, earned through services rendered during its securement after my father's unfortunate demise. My mother is at her wits end, resorting to fits of screaming her peace and yet to no avail. And of late my loathful step father, though to issue him such a name debases me, has taken to securing his self assumed rights with physical violence. Physical violence! Against my own mother, in the house I grew up in, under the roof I was taught to respect my mother country, the rule of law, and most importantly the righteous institution of family. I have had enough sir, and come to seek your help, guidance, and advice in my very personal matter."
Holmes sat for quite some time, his fingertips firmly pressed together, while he sat in his chair, deep in concentration. The young maiden herself nervously sat very stiffly, waiting, hoping, for the help she was sure was to come.
Suddenly, Holmes spoke up, rising from his chair as he did so. "My dear lady, I can not comprehend why you have come to me in this matter. It is evident there is not any interest for me in your case. The details are common, the motives are base, there is a remarkable lack of ingenuity on the part of all parties involved, making exception for the part about the kennel, that was most charming, but that aside, there really is no reason for me personally to study or invest my considerable talents in your case, because, quite frankly, there is no case to be solved my darling dear."
I remained seated, nodding in the always sensible words of the imminent Mister Holmes when I saw the young miss stand with back straight, jaw set, and then, just when I assumed she would turn tail and politely, if absolutely upsetedly, beat retreat, she tightly drew together her radiant lips and saying nothing stalked up to the very form of my dear friend Sherlock Holmes and stared him straight in the eyes.
"Say something if you must, but I do hope you'll hurry along to your next appointment; I have important matters to attend to."
And it was then a most extra ordinary event occurred, for the young lady slapped Mister Sherlock Holmes, without his due respect, and then smugly and arrogantly told him: "Take all your capacities, my dear sir, and deign to solve out the mystery I've just given you with a sting to your cheek!" And so saying, and so leaving Holmes profoundly shaken, if not by the physical violence she so meanly resorted to, than most certainly by the deep mystery as to why she would have committed such an atrocity, she stormed out of our rooms on Baker Street.
For the next week, Holmes was out of sorts. I hardly saw him at all in my comings and goings, he never sat for meals, always taking them in his room or in his laboratory. His physical appearance grew increasingly disheveled and a real beard appeared among his features for the first time while I had known him.
At last, after a long week of this degrading behavior, I walked downstairs to breakfast to find Holmes sitting, shaved, hair combed, clothes neatly pressed reading a newspaper and enjoying a muffin.
"Good morning," said I. "It is a happy morning indeed to have you back amongst the living."
"Indeed, Mister Watson. And yet it is because I have a new case."
"Well, my good sir, what is the mission this time? Do tell."
"I fear the recent singularly tragic and remarkably enigmatic event of a soft velvet hand striking my cheek so sternly has left a certain sting my mind can not bear to release until such a time as I can say with the certainty only available through the logical processes capable by my faculties and due to undaunted practice, that I have resolved the Case of my Slapped Cheek. I should like to begin without any further delay. I shall go forth and discover where this family's kennel must be and then I shall come hither and retrieve you for a most assuredly great adventure."
And so it was I spent the morning reading papers and a few of the latest works of fiction until my friend and associate returned slightly before lunch. We ate quickly and then departed for our destination by coach.
We rode in silence as I am sure my companion was deep in introspective ponderings upon the matter at hand. We arrived in due time and exited the coach to the banter of barking dogs behind high walls. Our terminus was the house adjoined to the kennel; we rang the bell and were shown politely into the parlor by a woman of middle age, with what appeared to be growing strains on her face, her hair pulled back tightly into a bun, though rather raggedly. Grey streaked her auburn hair in parts and her eyes betrayed a burden. But she overcame whatever limitations she suffered and saw to her duties as hostess.
Her conversational abilities were sorely lacking, for distracted it was obvious she was. Holmes inquired after the state of her business only after giving our condolences for her loss of her husband and obvious mainstay of her life.
We were not long there before a guttural shout sounded from the back of the house. The Madame quickly excused herself and it was not a long period of time before we noticed over the background of dogs barking in the kennel, a deep, inarticulate screaming, a small whimpering voice pleading, and the unmistakable sound of a hard object striking soft flesh.
We rudely moved ourselves closer to the source of the commotion and found the lady of the house we had only just met standing in terror with tears streaming her face, her bodice ripped, and already black marks appearing and swelling growing across her once quite lovely, respectable cheeks. A man stood above her, sweating, hair akimbo, taut fingers gripping her throat, and fist held above his head, hanging waiting to pound down. He caught us out of the corner of his eye.
"Get out rogues! Remove yourselves! Can't you see I've got to take care of business back here? I have every right to treat my property as I see fit. Or do you gentlemen disagree?"
"Oh no, you are quite right, sir, and I am sure she is responsible for every thrash she must endure. No, we surely only came to bid the fair lady farewell, to thank her for her hospitality, and to see that she was still alive, for we shan't get far if we were to destroy all our precious womankind. And yet, you are quite right sir, we must indeed keep them in line, or all civilization would be obliterated. As it stands, we bid you adieu!"
We left the house in some rush, as our coach was still waiting. Once we settled into our seats on the slightly bumpy ride, Holmes said, "Alas, I must now return to my terrible l'état d'ennui."
"What?" I said, "have you solved the mystery."
"Why of course my dear Watson. How could I not? In any case, it was not so hard to see."
"My fine sir, then, do tell. Is it a single villian? Is it some deep conspiracy? Who is the evil mastermind? Where may we find him? And forget not the infallible logical process you used to come to your final solution."
"Sadly, Watson, we are all accomplice to the horrible crimes we have witnessed today. But Happily, I have discerned the reason, the reason for such a beautiful violet eyed figure to strike me firmly enough for the sting to still remain in my cheek at least a week, but also the reason for the strikes we were present for today.
"You see, Watson, in order for civilization, and to be specific, the civilization of Man, to birth itself, we had to domestic not cow, not sheep, not dogs, but the wildest of all the creatures of the earth: Woman. Here lies the great conspiracy of Mankind, the dark secret, hidden, obscured, and suppressed to the point where we consider it natural for a man to beat a woman, for humanity to be violent and suspicious of each other, and for us all to possess the desire to dominate in a perceived, yet imaginary contest. Previously, there was indeed a garden of Eden, a place of peace for all life, living together connected. But somewhere, somehow, there came a terrible terror over the minds of men. Some society, somewhere could no longer calm our fears, indeed, no doubt manipulated our fear into raw, aweful, violent power. Because man suddenly isolated himself from himself, from his kind, from his women, from his collaboration with life, from his garden, from his forest, from his role in the sympathy of the cycle of nature; because man detached himself, through a mysterious process lost in the mysts of foggy time, Man propelled himself to the top of a food chain through physical violence, self induced by rabid fear, and established himself as ruler over a ruled who had never needed ruling before. Man victimized himself so he could victimize and we have all suffered for that original sin ever since. But women most especially so, because we men understand that if we are to maintain the delusion that we are afraid, that we need fear to create the violence that creates the awesome power we wield to dominate the earth and the mother and each other, we must destroy the womanly divine power to heal, to grow, to birth, and to rebirth.
"It is probable that all the sinister acts of our time and of all history stem directly from the events described by my elucidation. We must promise in the future, we must endeavor to be more willing to assist the weaker and more charming sex in their fights against injustice. But that is for the future. As for now, my dear Watson, I dare say we may well have saved a life today and my mind at least is at ease; my relentless desire to discern the darkest of mysteries has been appeased by our investigation. So, now I say let us fight tiresome boredom by making our cook do her duty and make us food without getting her share of the goods while our maid cleans the clothes we have so unfortunately weathered during the escapades of our adventure to-day."
And so it was. We never discussed the matter again.